Australian
Society for Medical
Entrepreneurship
& Innovation
ASME, home
All resources
Essay7 min12 Mar 2026

What clinical training already gave you for the founder job

Counterfactual reasoning, evidence weighting, performance under uncertainty, and the bad-news conversation. Eric Topol has been writing for fifteen years about the cognitive overlap between bedside medicine and frontier technology. Here is what travels.

By Dr Anu Ganugapati

Essay

The diagnostic instinct and customer discovery

The first skill a medical student is drilled in, before any of the science, is taking a clinical history. Open-ended questions. Tolerating silence. Following the patient's narrative before testing the differential. The structure is the same as a competent customer-discovery interview. The complaint is the symptom. The customer's day is the systems review. The workflow they tolerate is the past medical history.

The transferable habit is to start broad and narrow only after the patient has stopped speaking. The clinician's instinct to suppress confirmation bias in a clerking exam is exactly the instinct most non-clinical founders have to learn the hard way through dozens of bad customer interviews.

Counterfactual reasoning

Eric Topol, the cardiologist, founder of the Scripps Research Translational Institute, and one of the most influential writers on clinician-led innovation, frames clinical decision-making as fundamentally counterfactual. Clinicians, he argues, frequently use conditional reasoning, envisioning potential outcomes for patients in alternative treatment arms before acting. This is the cognitive engine of clinical reasoning, and it is functionally identical to the cognitive engine of product strategy.

Founders who can hold multiple counterfactual product futures in mind, weigh the evidence for each, and act on the highest-expected-value path are doing the same thing the clinician at the bedside is doing. The vocabulary is different. The shape of the work is the same.

Evidence weighting in product decisions

Medical training drills a hierarchy of evidence into the trainee through repetition. Randomised controlled trial. Cohort study. Case series. Case report. By the time you finish residency the hierarchy is unconscious.

Founders without that hierarchy confuse anecdote with signal constantly. One enthusiastic customer becomes the basis for a roadmap. One angry user kills a feature. The pattern, viewed from clinical reasoning, looks like a junior doctor weighting one bad outcome from a case report higher than a meta-analysis of fifteen studies. The fix is to apply the hierarchy to product evidence. Ten quantitative survey responses beat one charismatic interview. A controlled cohort of free-trial users beats a vocal power user.

Performance under uncertainty

By graduation, a clinician has made decisions about other people's bodies with incomplete data, in compressed time, while tired, while watched, and while accountable. The medical literature on clinical reasoning under uncertainty is vast and well-validated, and it is the closest cognitive analogue to the day-to-day reality of running a venture-backed company.

Most non-clinical founders have never had to operate at this level of stakes. Their pattern under uncertainty is to ask for more data, defer the decision, or seek a senior person's permission. The clinician's pattern is to gather what is available, reason explicitly, choose, and own it. That asymmetry compounds, because the decision shows up dozens of times a week in a company.

What to unlearn

There is one place medicine misleads you, and it is worth naming. Medicine teaches that the safe path is to escalate. When you do not know, you call your senior. When you are uncertain, you order another test. The cost of an unnecessary call is small. The cost of missing a diagnosis is enormous.

Founder life inverts the asymmetry. The cost of escalation, of deferring to the smartest investor in the room or hiring a senior to make a call you should have made yourself, is the dominant cost in the early years. The cost of being wrong is small, because you find out fast and you correct. Notice the escalation instinct. Catch yourself. Make the call.

Topol's broader argument, across two decades of writing on clinician-led innovation, is that the cognitive equipment that makes a competent clinician at the bedside is precisely the cognitive equipment that makes a competent technologist at the frontier. Stop apologising for being a clinician. The apology is what is slowing you down.

Sources

  1. 01Wikipedia, Eric Topol biography and bibliography
  2. 02Eric Topol, The clinical potential of counterfactual AI models
  3. 03Eric Topol, The Paradox of Medical AI Implementation (Substack)
  4. 04Eric Topol, Deep Medicine: How Artificial Intelligence Can Make Healthcare Human Again

Written by Dr Anu Ganugapati · Published 12 Mar 2026